Herald's Notes 12/22/07 CONT'D

Archon Christine presides over the last two speakers for Socrates' defense.

Arnold, the non-socratic farmer who became well acquainted with Socrates, pointed out several matters that need to be taken into consideration. It seems that the Radical and Moderate Democrats are focusing solely on personal gain. They took the chance to vote away from a "poor" socratic and would do anything to dispose of someone who doesn't agree. In regards to the claims of impiety, Arnold stated that the democrats have failed to provide any proof. Socrates sacrifices when necesary. Socrates is not going against the gods, or suggesting anything else; he feels that Hesiod and Homer have cast the gods in a poor light. Arnold asks how we can convict someone who simply asks questions. Finishing his speech, Arnold reiterates that Socrates is a law abiding citizen who has done nothing wrong.

Arnold retakes his seat giving the podium to Oligarch Shannon.

Shannon addresses corrupting the youth. He points out that relations with young male followers is nothing new. Socrates does not receive payment, nor does he recognize anyone as students. He has voluntary followers. Shannon emphasizes the speeches preceding his with Socrates' only "crime" is that of asking questions.

With less applause than before, Shannon sits again.

Archon Christine calls for a vote.

The stones are in favor of finding Socrates guilty: 5-4

General Thrasybulus takes the podium and proposes, on behalf of all the democrats, exile for twenty years.

Socratic Brandon proposes erecting a memorial outside of Athens in honor of Socrates.

Calling for a vote regarding Socrates' penalty, the outcome is in favor of the General: 6-3